Skip to main content

Wearable technology is rapidly moving from novelty to mainstream. Smart glasses, which can capture photos, record video and transmit information in real time, are now readily available and increasingly finding their way into workplaces. While the technology offers potential productivity benefits, a recent decision of the Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia highlights the significant legal, safety and operational risks that can arise when employees use such devices at work.

In Martins Silva v Toll Transport, the Court upheld Toll's decision to dismiss an LPG truck driver who used smart glasses to take photographs while on site at Esso's Long Island Point LPG terminal. The terminal prohibited the use of electronic devices that were ‘intrinsically unsafe’ because of the risk that a spark could ignite highly flammable products. The employee was employed by Toll to transport LPG for Origin Energy and was required to access Esso's terminal to load fuel before undertaking deliveries.

The employee used the smart glasses to photograph a control panel and send the image to his manager. Following the incident, Esso immediately locked the employee out of the site and Origin Energy requested that he be removed from its work. Toll subsequently investigated the matter, finding that the conduct breached multiple workplace policies and the employee's contract of employment before ultimately terminating his employment.

The employee argued that his dismissal was unlawful because it was motivated by complaints he had made about safety issues. The Court rejected that argument, finding that the smart glasses incident was the real reason for the disciplinary action. Importantly, Judge Blake described the conduct as "objectively very serious" and observed that the employee was "plainly aware of the risks" associated with using the device at the terminal.

While the case arose in a high-risk environment involving dangerous goods, its significance extends well beyond the transport and energy sectors. Smart glasses present a range of emerging challenges for employers.

Unlike mobile phones, smart glasses can record photos, video and audio discreetly, often without other people realising they are being recorded. This creates obvious privacy concerns, particularly in workplaces that handle sensitive personal, commercial or confidential information. Employers may also have legitimate concerns about employees recording meetings, conversations, clients, customers or other workers without consent.

The technology can also create health and safety risks. In some workplaces, such as manufacturing facilities, warehouses, laboratories, mines, energy sites and transport operations, wearable electronic devices may create distraction risks or conflict with site-specific safety requirements. As the Toll case demonstrates, those risks can have serious consequences where hazardous materials or high-risk operations are involved.

The decision serves as a timely reminder for employers to review whether their existing policies adequately address emerging technologies. Many workplace policies deal with mobile phones and cameras but were drafted before smart glasses became widely available. Employers should consider whether their health and safety, privacy, surveillance, confidential information and acceptable use policies expressly regulate wearable recording devices and clearly communicate expectations to employees.

The growing concern about smart glasses is not limited to workplaces. Recently, South Australia's Courts Administration Authority classified smart glasses and similar eyewear capable of recording audio, video or images as restricted items and banned them from South Australian court buildings due to concerns about unauthorised recording. The Fair Work Commission has also indicated it is considering whether additional guidance regarding smart glasses may be required, while the Australian Privacy Commissioner is monitoring broader privacy issues associated with surveillance wearables.

As smart glasses become cheaper, more accessible and more sophisticated, employers are increasingly likely to confront questions about their use in the workplace. The Toll decision suggests that where employers have clear safety obligations and well-founded concerns about the use of wearable technology, serious disciplinary action, including dismissal, may be defensible. The challenge for employers will be ensuring that their policies keep pace with the technology before the next incident occurs.