Skip to main content

Incapacity dismissals are among the most difficult dismissal decisions employers face. Employers must balance operational needs, workplace safety, and the legitimate interests of employees who may be experiencing serious illness or injury.

A recent decision of the Fair Work Commission, Timothy Read v SRG Global Assets Pty Ltd (Read), serves as a timely reminder that employers should proceed cautiously when considering dismissals on incapacity grounds and should avoid relying on assumptions.

In Read, the employee was dismissed following an extended period of absence due to illness. The employer's stated reason for dismissal was the employee's prolonged incapacity and the absence of a foreseeable return-to-work date. The employer noted that employees are only protected from dismissal due to a temporary absence arising from illness or injury for up to three months. The Commission ultimately found that there was no valid reason for dismissal and held that the employer had failed to properly assess the employee's capacity before ending the employment relationship.

Exceeding Three Months Does Not Create a Right to Dismiss

A common misconception is that an employee who has been absent for more than three months due to illness or injury can be dismissed, without legal risk.

This misunderstanding arises from the interaction between s 352 of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) and reg 3.01 of the Fair Work Regulations 2009 (Cth). Section 352 prohibits an employer from dismissing an employee because of a temporary absence from work due to illness or injury. Regulation 3.01 provides that an absence will generally cease to be a "temporary absence" where it exceeds three months continuously or totals more than three months over a 12-month period, subject to certain exceptions.

Critically, however, the expiry of that three-month period does not create a right to dismiss. Rather, it simply means that the specific protection in s 352 no longer applies. Employers must still be able to demonstrate a valid reason for dismissal and comply with the requirements of procedural fairness. As the Commission observed, the three-month timeframe merely defines what constitutes a "temporary absence" for the purposes of s 352. It does not mean that "all bets are off" after three months.

Capacity Must Be Assessed on Proper Evidence

The central criticism of the employer's conduct in Read was that it made assumptions about the employee's prognosis that were not supported by medical evidence.

Although the employee had supplied medical certificates stating that he was unfit for work during various periods, those certificates did not suggest that he suffered from a permanent incapacity. Rather, they reflected an ongoing process of treatment, assessment and review. The Commission noted that the employer relied on the absence of a foreseeable return-to-work date despite not taking steps to ask the employee, or his treating practitioners, for further information regarding his likely return.

The Commission also observed that the employer was aware that the employee had undergone significant surgery and was being assessed for further treatment. In those circumstances, the Commission considered that a more appropriate course may have been to obtain additional medical evidence, including through an independent medical examination, before reaching any conclusion about the employee's long-term capacity.

The decision confirms that employers must base incapacity decisions on current and reliable medical evidence, carefully consider the employee's prognosis, and avoid drawing conclusions about future capacity in the absence of appropriate medical information.

Procedure Matters

The decision also serves as a reminder that incapacity dismissals are not exempt from the requirement to provide procedural fairness.

Even where an employer has genuine concerns about an employee's ability to perform the inherent requirements of their role, those concerns should be clearly communicated to the employee. The employee should be given a meaningful opportunity to respond and to provide further medical information where appropriate. Any material put forward by the employee should be genuinely considered before a final decision is made.

Employers should also actively explore reasonable alternatives before proceeding to dismissal, particularly where there is a realistic prospect of recovery or return to work. Failing to undertake these steps may undermine the employer's ability to demonstrate that it acted reasonably, even where the absence has been lengthy.

Key Takeaways for Employers

Read is a useful reminder that incapacity dismissals require an evidence-based and procedurally fair approach. Lengthy absence alone will rarely be enough to justify termination. Before taking action, employers should ensure they have properly assessed the employee's capacity, obtained adequate medical evidence, and engaged with the employee throughout the process.

Employers should:

  • Not treat a three-month absence as a trigger for dismissal.
  • Obtain current and reliable medical evidence before making any decision about ongoing capacity.
  • Assess whether the employee can perform the inherent requirements of the role, with reasonable adjustments, either now or within a reasonably foreseeable timeframe.
  • Consult with the employee and provide a genuine opportunity to respond to any concerns.
  • Consider obtaining an independent medical examination where the medical position is unclear or complex.
  • Maintain detailed records of the information relied upon and the steps taken during the decision-making process.

The key lesson is simple: the end of the three-month "temporary absence" period is not the end of the inquiry. Before dismissing an employee on incapacity grounds, employers must still carefully assess capacity, obtain appropriate evidence and ensure the process is procedurally fair.

If you are dealing with a prolonged employee absence or considering an incapacity dismissal, Mellor Olsson’s Employment and Workplace Law team can help you understand your obligations and navigate the process. To discuss your circumstances, contact our team on 8414 3400.